Buying guide
Sieves and Flour Sifters: Do You Need Both?
Fine sieves, drum sieves and crank sifters compared, and when sifting actually matters.
Ad: this guide contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you (how we make money).
A sieve removes lumps, adds a little air and combines dry ingredients evenly. One good fine-mesh sieve covers most baking.
Our shortlist
Shortlist in progress
We only list products once their specifications have been checked against the manufacturer or retailer. Until then, use the criteria in this guide to compare what's available.
Where to buy
Browse current options and prices at the retailer. These are affiliate links: we may earn a commission, at no cost to you (disclosure).
Types
| Type | Best for |
|---|---|
| Fine-mesh round sieve | Flour, icing sugar, straining sauces: the all-rounder |
| Drum sieve (tamis) | Very fine purées and large quantities of flour |
| Crank or squeeze sifter | Dusting and sifting straight into a bowl with one hand |
| Small tea-strainer size | Dusting icing sugar over a finished cake |
Look for
- Stainless steel mesh that won't rust.
- A hook or ears on the rim so it rests on a bowl.
- A comfortable handle if you will sieve a lot.
When sifting matters
Always sift icing sugar and cocoa, which clump. For flour in sponges, sifting helps mix in the raising agent evenly.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to sift flour?
For sponges, sifting helps mix the raising agent evenly. Always sift icing sugar and cocoa, which clump.
Is a sieve or a flour sifter better?
One good fine-mesh sieve covers most baking. A crank sifter is handy for one-handed sifting straight into a bowl.
What sieve is best for dusting a cake?
A small, tea-strainer-sized fine sieve gives an even dusting of icing sugar.
How we choose
BeneRecipes compares tools using manufacturer specifications and retailer listings. We have not tested these products ourselves and don't publish star ratings. We explain which type suits which cook and why.
Some links are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.
