Buying guide
Scone Cutters: Plain or Fluted?
Which cutter gives the tallest scones, and what sizes to buy.
Ad: this guide contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you (how we make money).
The cutter affects how well your scones rise. A sharp edge cuts cleanly; a blunt one squashes the sides together and stops them rising.
Our shortlist
Shortlist in progress
We only list products once their specifications have been checked against the manufacturer or retailer. Until then, use the criteria in this guide to compare what's available.
Where to buy
Browse current options and prices at the retailer. These are affiliate links: we may earn a commission, at no cost to you (disclosure).
Plain or fluted?
| Plain | Fluted | |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Classic straight-sided scone | Crinkled edge, often used for sweet scones |
| Rise | Very even | Also good, if the cutter is sharp |
| Also for | Welsh cakes, biscuits, crumpet rings (deep ones) | Biscuits, jam tarts |
Sizes
About 5 cm makes small afternoon-tea scones; 6–7 cm gives a generous individual scone. Nested sets cover every size.
Look for
- A sharp cutting edge (stainless steel keeps its edge).
- Tall sides, taller than the dough.
Technique
Dip in flour, press straight down and lift straight up. Never twist: it seals the edge and gives lopsided scones.
Frequently asked questions
Why should I not twist the cutter?
Twisting seals the edges, which stops scones rising evenly. Press straight down and lift straight up.
What size scone cutter is best?
About 5 cm for small afternoon-tea scones; 6–7 cm for a generous individual scone.
Plain or fluted cutter?
Either works if the edge is sharp. Plain is classic for scones; fluted is often used for sweet scones and biscuits.
How we choose
BeneRecipes compares tools using manufacturer specifications and retailer listings. We have not tested these products ourselves and don't publish star ratings. We explain which type suits which cook and why.
Some links are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.
